Showing posts sorted by date for query Natural Capitalist. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Natural Capitalist. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Tuesday, 6 October 2026

The Greens and the Zionists

The Green Party recently declared Zionism racism—a move that has deeply offended pro-Israel supporters and split the party. It's a striking reversal from when I was a member.

I once campaigned for Beddington Farmlands and even stood as a Green councillor. Back then, I landed in trouble at a tribunal for allegedly writing something antisemitic HERE. My actual offence? Pointing out that the owners destroying our local reserve were Jewish cousins—and suggesting we appeal to the Jewish community for help. This was before the more recent 'wars' in Gaza and Iran, at the peak of left-wing cancel culture.

How times change.

I've since left all political parties. Beddington taught me that democracy is a farce—we live in a corporate dictatorship wearing a democratic mask. With Trump and current world events, the mask is slipping entirely.

I now describe myself as an eco-social anarchist/natural capitalist/eco-socio technocrat—a mouthful I basically invented which translates broadly as a modern birder/naturalist. It reflects my hopelessness with party politics and my belief that family, friends, personal enterprise, and like-minded connections with the birding/natural history community are the only way forward.

The Greens are a perfect case study in why party politics fails. Under Zach Polanski and populists like Hannah Spencer, the party has morphed into a gloves-off anti-capitalist, anti-West outfit, courting Muslim and anti-Zionist voters. It was always anti-capitalist—it began as a communist brand, later buried under environmentalism and socialism.

Meanwhile, Elon Musk—the world's first trillionaire—promises global communism via Super Intelligence: abundance so great we'll only work for pleasure, all sustained by universal basic income. Good news for birders. Marx predicted communism as capitalism's inevitable end—maybe he was right. Or maybe the oligarchs are planning genocide and mass enslavement through an AI they control. Probably both.

Back to the Greens. They're the most democratic party—members vote on policy. I helped write and vote on nature conservation policy myself. Yet their leader, Polanski, didn't even vote in the Zionism referendum and reportedly opposes it. The members lead, not the leader—and that's democracy's fatal flaw.

The party has U-turned from the antisemitism stance I was disciplined over to declaring Zionism racism—the ultimate antisemitism—all to court Muslim votes prsumably. It's a testament to party politics' runaway narratives, unconstrained because it's utterly irrelevant to anyone with real power.

The Greens will never challenge the Zionist-spearheaded Western military-industrial complex before Super Intelligence arrives. Then whoever owns that intelligence controls everything—and Zionists, with their major tech holdings and global influence, will likely be major stakeholders. Unlike the UK Green Party.

Meanwhile, the real revolution—the rise of Super Intelligence, the global elite controlling it, and the undemocratic new world they're building—happens entirely outside politics, with values dictated by tech dictators and eventually non-human ones.

Party politics is just silly noise that is becoming incresaingly absurd.  

Tuesday, 4 March 2025

Natural Capital Investment Update

Early on in the year I normally do a quick update on our journey into natural capital investment which started about five years ago. Background on this HERE and last year's update HERE.

To keep this short, a lot has happened in five years but the main change has been a global pendulum shift to the right and the establishment of several anarcho-capitalist states, including to a large degree the US (although Trumponomics is an odd mix of anarcho-capitalism with tarriffs)  which is currently down sizing it's state (via Musk's DOGE) and transferring more wealth and power to the billionaire oligarchy.  

This is basically pretty bad news for liberals and lefties but also not good news for the Green Transition and Natural Capitalism (right wing environmentalism). The US is not a real billionaire oligarchy (like Russia) because there is still a relative spread of wealth in the US but it's the closest the US has come in modern times to being one which means the only real hope for nature at the moment is if one billionaire is a birder and decides to blow the lot on nature reserves. Considering these billionaires own the equivalent wealth of millions of poeple, one billionaire could out perform the RSPB or Birdlife International or the World Wildlife Fund in a stroke. Fingers crossed someone steps up to the plate.

In the abscence of a billionaire nature mogul it's not looking great out there and from my limited perspective I can't see many investment opportunities. As part as the shift away from neoliberalism and towards right wing anarcho-capitlaist populism there has been a massive retreat from Environmental Social Governance (ESG aka ethical capitalism) in both compliance and a retreat in management funds and ETFs investing in ESG companies. Some ESG funds have adapted by including arms manufactering into their portfolios on the basis of fighting Putin is ethical- a novel definition of the word ethics made fashionable in the Palestinian conflict.  Carbon prices are on the floor on for instance the Californian Carbon Credit exchange (holding up better in Europe) and the voluntary carbon market is just a joke and being exploited by corporations to offset carbon at a few quid a tonne (carbon needs to be about £150 a tonne to have any meaningful impact on markets). Even the UN Biodiveristy COP has resorted to a global nature fund that basically corporations invest in, then that money is invested in global markets, the corporations get part of that profit and a small fraction remaining then goes on nature. Just sounds a bit flawed as the fund could invest in destroying nature and making profit from that. 

Here in the UK what has happened to the laudable proposed changes proposed in the post EU-exit, Agricultural and Environmental Bills? Seems like a lot of the more ambitious objectives have been rolled back and only minimal progress made on the Nature Recovery Network, Sustainabale Farming Initiative and Biodiversity Net Gain framework is pretty flawed too. The latest on the Beddington Farmlands project is that Valencia are trying to use BNG to water down conservation objectives in their new planning application. It's just exhausting what is going on there and simply highlights the fundamental flaws of corporate led nature conservation. Will update soon following the embargo on some strictly confidential developments. 

I've been following the Green Finance Institute over the last few years and after a initial period of optimism and even growth in many areas, it now seems that most Green Finance ideas are turning into fantasies with the Task Force for Nature Related Disclosures being their lead initiative for biodiversity which all seems a bit fuzzy to me (some of their green transport initiatives seems less fanciful). 

So basically, I would certainly welcome any feedback from anyone who knows more about this than I do but as a private natural capital investor I can't see any opportunities at the moment apart from maybe buying carbon credits when they are very cheap? I think any investment is tricky at the moment- a global recession is well overdue and could get triggered by this Trump-Musk-Putin alliance and a global trade war is literally kicking off today, the buy-to-let market is barely profitable, US stock indices are at all time high but looks like are beginning to fall (the Trump bump is already over), crypto looks like its beginning to fall after all time highs too despite the announcement of a crypto reserve by Trump. Who knows we could be on the verge of a global meltdown? One source of optimism for me is a global meltdown that initiatives a global AI reboot that integrates natural capital indices into it's algorithm. 

As I meant to keep this short, I'll wrap this up. As Charlie Munger said, the main thing about investing is not to do anything stupid. I think that's true and seems like doing anything at the moment is pretty stupid so my investment advice to myself this year is do nothing (apart from keeping the projects ticking over and growing slowly HERE). Maybe save any spare cash and wait for an opportunity to appear (interest rates are still high so getting 4-5% in an ISA will probably outcompete US major indices and shift to Treasury Bonds if interest rates keep coming down) or blow it all on birding trips or pay some of the mortgage off if the interest rates don't come down. I like the sound of option two most!

Friday, 12 January 2024

For what it's worth

Sorry for the off-topic post but I can't stay focused when I can see that everything is connected. For what ever my tiny opinion is worth I do think that the fate of the natural world will be decided by a system of global governance that humanity co-evolves into. Maybe it's not very convincing to say that nature conservation is linked to the Israel-Gaza war but what that crisis highlights is that there is no international police force or army that the people of Gaza can call to help them. Global society is basically an anarchy and that anarchy leads to a race to the bottom, an economic and technological arms race of superpowers and lesser powers fighting for dominance. There are no governing structures that maintains an order (particularly in the control of murder)  in the same way a state entity does and the closest thing we have to a world government is the UN which is overall a toothless, target setting talking shop and gravy train. 

Only necessity i.e. global breakdown and chaos can create the necessary conditions for a post-Capitalist system that distributes wealth and power in a more equitable fashion and also protects nature which is the foundation to our species survival.

Maybe the situation in Israel will facilitate that global breakdown. At the moment there seems to be a growing outrage at the shameless massacre of children that the IDF are perpetrating.  If the far right Zionist Israeli government have pushed things too far which makes it impossible for their allies to keep defending their military strategy that involves child massacre, they could open a fault line between the century old US-Israel-Europe alliance and we could start to see traditional geopolitical superstructures disintegrating. For what it's worth I don't think what Israel is doing is overall morally defendable but I also think that Hamas and the Arabs would do the same or worse to Israel if only they could so I'm certainly not taking sides- just noting that chaos reigns when there is no global government that can split these two fighting factions apart.  If the Ukraine situation escalates too we really could be on the brink of global meltdown in 2024. Certainly worth taking some precautions and insurances.  

There will be nothing pleasant for anyone in a global breakdown and it is certainly nothing to celebrate but after a necessary horrifying and painful period of history the world could end up in the place it needs to get to for planetary ecosystems, the climate and humanity to stabilise. Seems like there is no other way but the most difficult way.   
    

Tuesday, 2 January 2024

Happy? New Year

Seems like an increasing miracle every new year that begins against the backdrop of escalating global chaos. My social media feed nowadays contains news from WP birding friends at war in Israel, birding friends struggling in the shadow of the Ukraine situation in Bulgaria, the usual global and climate emergency stuff, planning system meltdown at Beddington and the expectation of financial system collapse, the threat of AI, environmental authoritarianism, social credit and digital currency totalitarianism or the next pandemic. 

Trying to make personal and small enterprise decisions in an unstable global context is a bit of a lottery but the key principles of personal resilience, risk exposure limitation and a diverse and flexible strategy seems to make sense in order to generate better odds.

Our main aim of 2024 is to move into our new family homestead and set up the garden food growing again before the global economy collapses which is all a bit worrying as it might happen tomorrow or in months/years time. In my opinion after the bailouts of the 2008 global financial collapse and the resulting QE and business as usual approach, a new bigger and more devastating financial bubble was inevitable. That bubble has now got a name - the Everything Bubble HERE and when that bubble bursts the world will presumably enter some kind of post-fundamental Capitalist epoch- new AI-powered digital currencies, multi-indices, social credits, carbon credits, natural capital etc. The bubble could deflate slowly or suddenly and the impacts are anyone's guess - new opportunities will appear and old ones will disappear.   

So hopefully before anything too dramatic happens we can get to safe ground and have a bit of land to live off and focus on wider efforts from a safe position.  We also will have a chance to improve the EPC rating of the property and build in some energy self sufficiency to try and get things as cost effective as possible. We hope to move into an area where nature reserves, beaches and other natural resources are within walking distance so if we do experience lockdowns and movement limitations (due to becoming broke!) there could be worst places to be.

If I was still living in an urban or communal setting I would do what I did back then too and do community food growing and local community building around nature and natural resilience. The thing about this stuff is global collapse or not, it still increases personal well being and adds value so you can't lose.  

So the most powerful personal resilience (next to being global elite, engineering the collapse and gorging off the death and destruction that follows) in the face of so many uncertainties is connecting to nature and mainly living off the sustenance that watching birds and wildlife and cultivating nature brings detached somewhat from human systems and costs. While it might seem not a great thing if the global financial system collapses it's almost inevitable that some stress will be taken off  nature as a result and new opportunities will emerge for more people to reconnect to nature. Leaning on nature when the consequences of our collective short-term wiring back fires is one of our best hopes for a happy new year . 

Monday, 7 August 2023

Natural Capitalist Update

Thought I would do an update on this, previous ramblings HERE. At the end of 2021 and beginning of 2022 we set ourselves an investment plan HERE in order to finance a private nature reserve/homestead in the UK and develop other areas of our natural capital interests.

Within a month of that plan Russia invaded Ukraine and there has been an energy crisis, a cost of living crisis, rapid inflation and large interest rate rises. In addition to the global crisis we have also had personal crisis with bereavement and large death tax bills to settle plus other increased tax liabilities and looming high interest rate payments.  As in all chaotic situations that has provided both lost opportunities and new opportunities. 

Following the plan HERE here is an update on some of those investment objectives:

1) Investment in Beddington Farmlands hinterland buy to let market

The two rental properties there are going well and yielding about 4% which is now lower than we can get in a bank savings account since the interest rate rises. Once the fixed term expires on the buy to let mortgage in 4 years time, if the interest rate has not gone down,  this will be a disaster. Therefore the objective is to pay off that mortgage as soon as possible. What with property prices on the slide and interest rates on the rise, this is not a good time at all to make further investments in this space and in fact its a good time to exit any exposure to the new interest rates. 

2) Investment in Green Finance (Funds and Stocks and shares in the green transition) 

I have done a bit of research in this field and made some good returns on investments in TESLA but overall this is a very unsafe space and I have seen losses in Carbon capture ventures (such as Aker), green transition funds (Jupiter Green) and even the UK's first natural capital PLC company (Foresight) is also showing a loss in share price since the heady heights of the hysteria surrounding COP26 and the company's IPO. Also one of the largest decarbonisation ETFs that I tried (HANetICAV) has also failed to get momentum. I'm about 15% down overall and friends of mine that have pensions in this space have made significant losses. We have inadvertently been subsidising the green transition which is probably a better way of spending money than giving to an Environmental Charity but that wasn't the goal :-) I suppose it can all go down as carbon footprint offsets. 

Since then I've been watch-listing as many eco-start ups, green transition ETFs and green transition companies as possible and from what I can work out the whole area of Green Finance has really been hit hard by the Global Economic Crisis with a real cooling off as attention has turned to food security, energy prices, global security, global financial security and risk aversion to new green start up financing. So for instance various investment tips from CarbonCredits.Com have proved to be bad advice with Carbon Steaming Corporation, Devvstream Holdings (carbon credit block chains), Brookfield Renewables (a well established decarbonisation engineering company) , Ishares Global Clean Energy ETF (100 clean energy companies fund), Nasdaq Clean Edge Green Energy ETF, VanEck Low Carbon Energy ETF and their Green Bond ETF all not performing very well and many making losses (large losses in some cases). 

The main Green Finance initiatives that are making money seem to be the ones that follow large index funds like the IShares MSCI ACWI Low Carbon ETF, the SPDR MSCI ACWI Climate Paris Agreement Aligned ETF and the SPDR S&P 500 Fossil Fuel ETF but that is basically because they more or less track the corresponding index funds that have been rallying for most of this year (but started to dip in the last few days). Also large blend funds like the Blackrock Carbon Transition ETF are doing okay and also the Kraneshares Californian Carbon Allowance ETF has been on the up as it tracks the carbon price in the Californian mandatory carbon market (whereas the Kraneshares ETF that gives exposure to the mandatory European Carbon market price hasn't performed as well and global carbon price market exposures by Kraneshare have been very poor). 

So I really don't know where to go with this and the main area for profit seems to be in the ETFs that simply follow the main indices which have probably peaked for now anyway. I've set up a Charles Schwab trading account to access (mainly dollar) investments not available on Hargreaves Lansdown but I think will wait to see if this recession, that everyone is waiting for,  appears before going back in. It all seems either at peak or unpredictable so I'll adopt a patient, sit and wait approach and look out for a strong pattern to move on.    

3) Purchasing of Land/ Natural Capital
No further gains made in this area but have made progress with the development of one acre of Natura 2000 habitat that we have purchased in Bulgaria and intend to expand in the future. 

4) Growth in Core business activity of Green Space Management 
This has certainly been maintained with good figures for 2022/2023 in recent accounting results.

5) Monetisation of Projects 
No progress made here, in fact been withdrawal from the Azores Project to loss in volunteers.

6) Investment in cryptocurrencies and block chain 
Despite all the hype and predictions of a new crypto bull run nothing much happening with any of this from what I can see. My small stake in Bitcoin, Solana, Ethereum and Litecoin  has been bouncing on the bottom after the slight bounce back in late 2022/23 after the November 2022 crash (and FTX collapse). 

7) Continue investment in current land and property assets 

We started a big project at the beginning of this year to build another apartment on top of an existing one in Malta- things are moving slowly but forward with that.

Of course the big development here is the selling of the Old Vicarage which following death tax, inheritance distribution and costs will place money into the homestead/private nature reserve fund. However with sliding property prices and the tight time scales involved we will probably invest that money and take advantage of the high interest rate opportunities and sit things out a bit while waiting to find the best site and hope to capitalise on the rising interest rates and falling property prices. Fingers crossed! 

So all in all, lots of reshuffling and refocusing of objectives in order to track the moving target but all going pretty good, we were aiming for about £2 million by 2026 to support the private nature reserve/homestead and that is not looking over ambitious. However the scale of the project might be scaled down as the last couple of years have shown that its not a good idea to have too many eggs in one basket so might look for a smaller site (one to three acres) and finance that from income across a small constellation of investments and focus on the Bulgaria project to meet the larger scale objectives (where land is cheaper). As always anything can happen so will see what happens next. As usual seems like the best investments are investing in your own businesses, property and projects with passive income from outsourced investment (ETFs, stocks and shares and savings etc) always seem to be more effort than their worth (in my limited layman experience).  I think maybe some of the appeal of mainstream passive income investments is the hyped promises of fast easy money, the delusion of safety in numbers (billionaires eat small investors by their millions in each mouth full), coupled with the psychological effect of sunken loss both in intellectual and capital investment plus the emotional bonding to some of these investment narratives. According to some sources only ten percent of investors make money from the stock market which also sets a psychological challenge to win which all adds up to quite an addictive and dangerous cocktail. Safer to invest in your own private assets and businesses I would definitely say but not as fun as playing the big (the biggest) game. 

Wednesday, 24 May 2023

Inequality and Natural Capital

Everyone knows (and feels)  that when it comes to economic wealth, the UK is a very unequal society and that inequality is growing over time (after falling for decades from the Victorian period it started rising again in the last couple of decades and that has accelerated since the financial crash in 2008 and it accelerated even faster during Covid). 

According to Google: 

In 2020, the ONS calculated that the richest 10% of households hold 43% of all wealth. The poorest 50%, by contrast, own just 9%. More than that, for the UK as a whole, the WID found that the top 0.1% had share of total wealth double between 1984 and 2013, reaching 9%.

A couple of images below show this inequality and the trend over time. 





Is there any disagreement that Fundamental Capitalism is now failing? I think the jury was out for a lot of the post-war period but I'm not sure there are many people now living in the UK that are happy with the prospect of inequality rising further and as we see more automation, big data systems and AI technology supplant existing systems the trend is only set to accelerate even further with more and more people being pushed into the low income class and the middle income class become smaller and smaller while the top percentiles increase exponentially. According to the World Economic Forum, one of the biggest challenges that western societies face in the future is mass obsolescence. There will almost certainly be a period where automation and AI will cause the loss of at least 25% of all jobs and a delay for new jobs to be created. There is also the possibility that it is simply impossible to replace all those jobs with new jobs and it looks like the era of 'not-real jobs' in government and charities is also scaling back and lets face it how many of us want to or are even capable of, are perky or interesting enough to do the new not-real jobs like having an Only Fans page, selling your farts on the internet, running a you tube channel or a big tik-tok following, being a successful online day trader or crypto investor or being an influencer. Let's face it, for a lot of humans, particularly if you live in the UK, it aint looking too good out there.  

So what does the collapse of Fundamental Capitalism look like? I think it looks like what we see around us happening now- , the increase in inequality, the extermination of the middle class, polarisation of society, lack of motivation, a lack of opportunity, a breakdown in stable societal structures and hierarchical structures, a mass demand for banality and not being able to see much of a future. Fundamentally it also looks like the disconnection of people from nature and natural systems.

I also think that alongside that collapse we are beginning to see what a post GDP paradigm will look like. Fundamentally upgrading Capitalism into Sustainable Systems involves the capturing of externalities into value models, basically bringing things in like the value of Ecosystem Services into the market place. It's all started already, carbon credits, natural capital accounting, net gain, net zero and all building on ESG frameworks and the roots of multi-metric systems. 

Indeed most of what is happening at the moment is green wash and bullshit and we are probably several extreme disasters (including wars of many shapes and forms) away from the kind of policy and technological changes that are required to actually move out of the GDP paradigm into a paradigm that measures growth in Ecological-Economic and Social terms.  Presumably any new system in the future will be firmly digital based using big data and AI to manage complex planetary (and interplanetary !) management challenges including the redistribution of wealth and new digital based hierarchical , reward and motivational systems plus ecological management and natural capital management. 

The more the GDP paradigm fails, the more hope there is for change. The worse things become the more hope there is for people to start demanding fundamental change. A lot of us are in a situation at the moment where things are shit but not shit enough to do anything about it. The wolves are howling out on the perimeter but they haven't crashed the doors down yet and started chewing on your nuts. That might be different for the new generation which are basically being thrown from the education bubble into the jaws of the canines so its more in their interest to drive these changes forward.  

If you ask me, there will be a new type of wealthy person to aspire to be in the future and we can already see that coming too with the rise in millionaire and private nature conservation. There is a new elite emerging- the Natural Capitalist, someone who doesn't show off their large mansion and fancy cars and material wealth but someone who is defined by how much natural capital they own- how many species are in the land they own or the territory they manage, how much carbon sequestration, what is there Nature Positive and Carbon Positive value? Corporations are beginning to take on this value system and following COP15 there are now UN policies being introduced where companies now need to start reporting on natural capital. Biodiversity is the next carbon and it looks like we are set to see Biodiversity credits and biodiversity markets appearing soon- something I would fall over myself to get involved in (unfortunately I'm just a pleb with no elite contacts so might just be a big fan of all this and maybe invest a bit in it).  

A new system needs a new Elite and what better type of Elite is there than an Elite that manages the planet sustainably and responsibly, drives the recovery of nature and generates more global equality. Personally I'm not a fan of Fundamental Communism or Socialism (I've always run my own business in a blended form of capitalist values and social and environmental models)  and I believe that a gentle hierarchy, a gentle inequality is a better solution, so enough incentive to climb and also enough  dire consequences if your lazy but not too steep and one with a large and healthy middle class.  The current way that nature is managed is mainly through NGOs which is basically a communist like structure where nature reserves are collectively owned. This doesn't work at scale as we know (just look at the biodiversity trends) and that needs to change too with a more private and market focus. 

Fundamental Capitalism and the GDP model (and nature being managed through collectives as a counter measure to that) was a crude way of dealing with the first stages of all this, just a way of dealing with abject poverty and creating global systems (at the expense of the environment and ecology) to form the foundations for the next stage of societal evolution. In that next stage I'd like to see a new middle class emerge, the Natural Capitalist middle class which is involved in a return to land ownership and nature, the dismantling of intensive agriculture and the rise of regeneration in private hands and the generation of a wealthy thriving private natural capital economy. At the moment this is already happening in the elite upper income class but a sustainable society needs a growing middle class in this sector. 

Fundamental Capitalism is indeed failing but a return to Nature and private nature ownership is ( for some of us), hopefully a solution. 

Saturday, 18 February 2023

Twists and turns

There have been a few twists and turns in our relocation project recently. Seems like it is indeed too premature to attempt buying a small farm with commitments to existing investments and family considerations. Also seems unlikely we will be able to do much further down the line too with current interest rates, costs of this imminent relocation and other family members emotional ties with this area. So basically it looks like another life plan is knackered which is a shame because one well positioned base  with self sufficiency potential seems to me to be the most resilient solution for any family. However I guess the most resilient solution for any family is to make sure everyone's emotional needs are met (practical and rational considerations often seem rather secondary) and if that means more grief for me than I suppose that's how it is. 

So a re-routing seems to be the mission at the moment which all seems like going round in a big circle. So if we can't get our own private haven it's back to engaging more in public nature. The farm plan always involved being close to a major public natural coastal resource anyway (e.g. a farm next to Pagham Harbour or the Thames Estuary) so this was always to do with a private/public weighting.

Personally speaking I need to have regular access to coastal birding and mothing as the migration and vagrancy element of nature is what really fires me up and keeps my light going. I think that is vital as if I'm not fired up and excited by life I won't be any kind of use/inspiration/lead/soul to drain for the boys.  So the new plan is for me to spend two days or so a week on the coast, first from my campervan and later when I can afford it maybe buy a small lodge or holiday home (the family can join me too that way). The benefit of me going alone now is Holly was not keen at all on the Thames Estuary (too industrial and gritty for her) but it's always been my dream to retire there so as one obstacle goes up another comes down. I'll then need at least one day in London working and then the other four days of the week I can be back here with Holly and the kids and work from home (I can also work on the road). Meanwhile where ever Holly decides to move to I'll do my best to make that new home as nature-centric as possible, I just hope she gets a decent garden! 

I would have preferred the coastal haven family base so we could be together all the time but like I say it's not my choice to make alone.  Seriously though I must be one of the few blokes on the planet who isn't allowed to settle down and gets forced into a selfish lifestyle by their partner! The madness is I was finally ready to settle down too and was quite enjoying the thought of not having to travel so much. Anyway natural forces know best so I'll go with it. 

It's going to make my personal carbon negative/nature positive footprint objective more difficult too. I was hoping we could use a private farmstead/nature reserve to go to town on that. In order to address that issue now I was planning on concentrating on moving more investment into the Bulgaria project (get more for your money there too). One mature tree is supposed to capture 21kg of carbon a year (one tonne over a 100 year life span as they don't capture so much carbon in early years) and the average carbon footprint of a UK citizen is 10 tonne of carbon a year. So basically each human needs to own about 700 to 800 trees for more or less the duration of their life (80 year life span). Soils, peats, wetlands and marine environments can capture more carbon so an individual could  own those resources too. Of course in addition to private ownership there is collective ownership too- e.g. by giving money to conservation NGOs, volunteering time to recording biodiversity for NGOs/research centres  or investing in private natural capital companies or owning an NGO or natural capital company too (like we do). 

I think we already own about 100 mature trees on the Bulgaria project so personally I would like to expand that to own 700 trees (seems a simple tangible target with established metrics). Then there's the carbon in the soil and grasses there too so that alone should mean I'm getting towards personal net zero. In addition there's all the trees and carbon sequestration resources we help to manage with Little Oak. While we can't add 100% of those resources to offset our personal footprints there must be some calculation to see what our share is of that e.g. there's tens of thousands of trees and wetlands etc planted at Beddington Farmlands alone (a resource we champion) and there must be tens of thousands across our gardens and green spaces we manage too. In addition there's the natural resources we own by investing in natural capital company shares and our 'shares' by supporting conservation NGOs too.

Anyway in the absence of these precise calculations at the moment the best approach seems to do absolutely everything we can to invest in as much carbon sequestration and natural capital as possible and to minimise our carbon consumption. That maximising investment while minimising consumption needs to be a well calculated trade off too (the reason why I've been a mild critic of the concept of low carbon birding in the past is that it simply concentrates on local carbon consumption reduction and not natural capital investment or wider collective natural capital ownership or re-designing global economic systems).  Presumably I'm not far off being nature positive/carbon neutral but also I mustn't forget about the kids (while they are under 18 I guess I am also responsible for another 20 tonnes a year!). Ultimately the solution is simple- just do everything I can without burning out. Meanwhile fundamental capitalist billionaires of the world carry on with their plan to achieve sustainability by driving billions of people to extinction or fates worse than death and they survive an apocalypse that they engineer and control (not sure that's going to work out well for them or everyone helping them do that as it means destroying their own planetary communities that they need to survive too) so there's that slight concern to circumnavigate too- trying to do this against that global destructive force. Fun times! 

So, that seems to be the general direction of travel at the moment- a more complex de-centralised strategy (aka 'I'm fucked') and seems like I'll have to wait for my private personal paradise- in the grave by the sounds of it.   

Thursday, 9 February 2023

GREEN FINANCE

I've added a couple of links to the Biding and Nature Politics section (viewable in the web version) of this blog.  I've added CarbonCredits.com and the Green Finance Institute (here) in addition to the links to Inkcap, Stock brokers, Nature Political Commentators and Green Politics Satire. Dieter Helm and the Green Finance Institute also have excellent podcasts on Spotify. 

Any regular reader of this blog will know how excited I am about the nature finance revolution. 30 years ago I was studying Environmental Science at University (Plymouth and Exeter) where multi-metric economies were first envisioned and  it has taken that long for these ideas to actually appear into real life (apart from tiny test tube rebel cells like our own Little Oak Group). I'm not sure it has dawned on everyone yet that this actually heralds the beginning of the end of Fundamental Capitalism as limits to growth are reached (expressed in the declaration of the climate and ecological emergency) and the costs associated with the externalities of Capitalism (including climate and ecological breakdown) are beginning to be subsumed into economic considerations, manifested in the adoption of the Polluter Pay principles and Public Money for Public Goods which have been transposed into initiatives and new legislation such as the Environment and Agricultural Acts through various vehicles such as the Net Biodiversity Gain Framework, Net Zero, the Sustainable Farming Initiative, ELMs and Carbon Credits. The government advisory body, the Natural Capital Committee headed up by Dieter Helm (an Oxford University lecturer aka the father of natural capital) were largely responsible for these changes and that committee has now been merged into the Office of Environmental Protection (OEP). It's a new system- basically at test stage.     

The next stage of this revolution is the most exciting for naturalists. Much of the system change so far has been about Carbon but there is still a long way to go before we have something similar to a tradeable biodiversity credit (although Net Gain has started this ball rolling) in the way we now have expanding tradeable Carbon credits and carbon markets. In a way the Climate Crisis is being addressed (by introducing carbon metrics) but the Ecological part of the Climate and Ecological Emergency is still largely un-resolved. All our bird and moth recording and all other citizen science will be going into developing a meaningful biodiversity credit which will be scaled up using e-DNA methods (e.g. where one water sample can tell you all the species in the water body as all animals leave traces of their DNA) and extrapolative modelling. There really does appear to be some light at the end of the tunnel now for biodiversity loss as a biodiversity metric/credit is the beginning of a biodiversity price which will eventually be reflected in the cost of goods basically pushing all consumers to buy regenerative goods and to drive unsustainable and value extraction corporations to extinction. Our system is currently unsustainable which literally means it cannot be sustained- it will (it already clearly is!) absolutely and certainly collapse (probably slowly but surely) but fortunately we now have a safety net developing and a new direction roughly worked out. The financial opportunities in all this are immense- the most powerful people in the future will be those who embrace this as early as possible.

It's interesting for me to see my first one of these Foresight Annual Report. I generally scour through Corporate Annual Reports to pick out their green washing and lies but this is the first one I've ever seen (maybe I'm a bit behind on all this) that is a Natural Capital Company listed on the stock market. As 95% of capitalist start ups fail within the first two years it will be interesting to see what the survival rate of this new age of Stock market listed companies will be. Certainly interesting times with immense new opportunities. How the unsustainable collapse and the sustainable rebuild inter-relate will be extremely interesting. 

Interestingly a reader of this blog messaged me recently commenting that I had come a long way from my Extinction Rebellion point of view (I was a co-founder of a local cell in 2019 and was a direct action activist). However as I pointed out, from my perspective that campaign fulfilled it's objectives- locally we got a Climate and Ecological Emergency declared in Sutton and globally the Climate and Ecological Emergency moved to the top of the political agenda and mainly since COP26 the Green Finance Revolution has started. The campaign worked and has started systemic change. I know it is not as fast and deep as some hoped but it certainly worked and got the ball rolling.  I agree the fact that it is not as fast and deep as it should be means that the collapse part of the collapse and rebuild of society will be much greater than theoretically needed (although the human condition has its natural limits which does not heed theory or rationality- basically we have to learn and change the hard way)  There's no point in continuing with disruptive direct activism when you've got what you wanted out of it. We were using the campaign locally to elevate Beddington Farmlands to the top of the local political agenda and that worked perfectly for us. I also got myself exiled from the local community which is a perfect position to be in for the final stage of the Beddington Farmlands campaign- an exiled rebel coming out of exile to help win the final battle is perfect for this story. A win that will almost certainly involve the new nature conservation system that has appeared since my exile- hopefully we will see an at scale test of this new system and what happens when it faces a disaster capitalist multi-billion dollar asset management company. Should be fun!  

So I have not in the slightest come a long way from my XR point of view, XR was part of this journey which we are building success on success. XR as an organisation itself (XR was actually a campaign of a larger well funded organisation called Rising UP) have also pledged to end public disruption for 2023. XR always said it was the alarm. The alarms have sounded and stopped- the bombs of Fundamental Capitalist Economic Collapse are now falling and the Sustainable Armies are aligning. 

Monday, 9 January 2023

Capitalist Realism

I was reading some stuff on Capitalist Realism today. I guess 50 years old must be a standard epiphany moment for many people who have experimented with alternative systems and socio-environmentalism. You get to 50 and nothing you do is working out the way you hoped; it kind of means its never going to work. I guess for me my main loss of faith is mainly due to just far too many 'betrayals' and lack of support but perhaps more so the realisation that keeping up high energy commitments which add or maintain natural and social capital over long periods of time just cannot compete with value extraction systems and it has nothing to do with 'educating' people or lack of choice (more or less everyone in the Beddington Farmlands project choose supporting value extraction and they were all highly informed of all the details).  It simply requires too much effort to avert value extraction so we are faced with a very frightening realism- capitalist systems will push us all to the brink of extinction and before anything fundamentally changes, we will have to nearly 'touch the sun' first. At some point the energy inputs to attempting to extract value will be higher than the energy inputs to regeneration e.g. if farmland is depleted so much that crops become increasingly more difficult and expensive to grow, it becomes cheaper and easier to use regenerative methods. There are plenty of examples were i.e. fish stocks have become depleted and local industry collapses which has led to quotas and sustainable fishing systems being introduced. 

So this is Capitalist Realism- value extraction, environmental decline and transfer of wealth into smaller and smaller group of elites (those who take the loot from destroying the planet facilitated by everyone who engages in the systems they govern)  is inevitable, disaster is inevitable and if there is any chance of recovery, disaster must come before recovery. 

Indeed there will always be examples that buck the trend of e.g. well managed nature reserves and parallel structures but these exceptions to the rules simply prove the rules and are also held together very weakly by trade offs and compromises (e.g. the way that the RSPB and Wildlife Trusts are mainly funded by blood money i.e. money earnt from the main Capitalist system e.g. Viridor funding these NGOs).  These exceptions are valuable in that they may well inspire recovery after disaster models but ultimately they are more likely to be out competed if ever main stream systems adopted some of their principles (like we have seen with natural capital companies like Foresight, L'Oreal funded Rewilding Estates and millionaire led nature conservation like Knepp etc suddenly exploding onto the scene challenging the NGO model as the ecological emergency intensifies and the first signs of mainstream change hoves into view) .  

In short, things have to get worse before they get better. However that short sentence means immense suffering and immense loss at global scale, possibly, probably, inevitably the greatest period of human suffering in all our history as we push our planetary life support systems to breaking point. At that breaking point there will be (if we project current population growth trajectories) maximum numbers of us living (fighting) to survive. The cracks are already appearing, the writing is on the wall and very few people are treating this emergency like an emergency. I'm not talking about a teenager fantasy held by the likes of Greta Thunberg appealing to those elites to stop this disaster (of course they fucking won't- they are engineers and designers of it, they are loving it all coming together as planned) but I'm talking about cretins like you and me. We can all see it coming but very few people are actually preparing adequately for it. Indeed plenty of people are using the threat of the emergency to gain political power or followings by sowing the seeds of false hope  i.e. capitalising on the threat as their way of surviving it. However if that's not your thing but surviving is then a bit of realism is helpful. 

Capitalist systems will push us all to the brink of extinction and there is nothing that can stop that. Hope is for fools.  That is Capitalist Realism. You are fucked, your kids future is fucked, nature is fucked, everyone is fucked (including the looters eventually and they know that which is why they are trying to stay on top of the collapsing pile, have multiple homes around the world with panic rooms and bunkers and private security forces and hoard as much as possible to last as long as possible) and very soon  we will all be fighting to the death (literally and metaphorically). Here’s the World Economic Forum saying that with a bit more class Here  


There is very little anyone can do about the situation but there is a lot that anyone can do to increase their chances of survival and helping to drive the evolution of the new sustainable systems. The only hope is in the hopelessness of Capitalism . 

Here's a little ditty from Thee Bryans about Capitalist Realism: The bubble will burst

Tuesday, 27 December 2022

Surviving the ecological emergency part 2

So here's part 2 of my sick bed ramble. Part 1 HERE. Basically I have no idea how anyone else is supposed to navigate through the self interest-infested waters of the climate and ecological emergency and the competing and conflicting narratives attempting to draw people into their control for better or worse. Like everything in this universe every poor wretched soul has to work out their own unique solution to thriving in the cosmic shit fest. The only advice I have to anyone is make sure you're full of your own bullshit and not some other fuckers', write your own narrative, specific to your unique and complex needs. 

So here's my bullshit. Here's how I'm trying to capitalise on this crisis. If anyone is genuinely passionate about nature the more naturalists capitalising from the crisis and building a new nature-centric system- the better.   

1. GET A STAKE IN THE GAME
You've got to be in it to win it. As nature becomes a more threatened and declining resource it becomes more valuable. The capitalisation of nature through Natural Capital Accounting, Carbon Credits, Biodcredits (announced recently at COP15), Offsets, Net Gain Frameworks, net zero and net positive frameworks, public goods for public money incentives etc etc have all exploded onto the big finance scene over the last two or three years. Seems like the game is up for charity CEOs like Carter Roberts, the CEO of the World Wildlife Fund who famously earns over $1,000,000 a year from the subscriptions we all give that bastard as now everyone can see they can get rich off the back of the ecological emergency. Instead of (just) giving that money to bank roll these charity moguls, believe in yourself and get in there. 

I wouldn't recommend anyone from the bottom of society (like me) invests directly in these new financial instruments and organisations yet. It's the wild west out there and the whole thing is full of scammers and self imploding start ups. I've invested in green transition funds, renewable energy companies, nuclear, carbon credit tokenisation block chains and carbon credit trading and I've lost on everything (although these are supposed to be long term investments- yes right, no room for bullshitting there) . Trying to pick a winner (and there will be some winners) in this gold rush is probably impossible without being on the inside track. If you thought crypto was full of scams, the whole carbon and nature offset stuff is even worse.  However if you're stupid like me, it's a bit of fun and interesting to watch how this whole thing develops because out of the melee- something useful and important will emerge. 

So I would definitely not recommend  investing in any of this new stuff unless you enjoy a flutter but I would definitely recommend that you buy actual natural capital- ie. land. Land is an investment anyway and in the future there will be added value for ecologically important land. So buy, buy, buy. Land is not particularly expensive, about £8000 an acre for agricultural land and is even cheaper in other parts of the world. 

As we begin to re-define concepts of wealth in the transition from a fundamental capitalist financial system to an ecosocio-capitalist 'financial' system, status symbols associated with dominance hierarchies will change. Celebrities and corporations are already falling over themselves to re-identify as being nature positive or carbon neutral. Even former Spice Girl Geri Halliwell has a rewilding project going on here in Oxfordshire. This stuff will trickle down into middle and lower income society with a growing trend of people owning estates or houses with rewilded areas of land and natural capital. For some people the main appeal of a property could be not how many bedrooms the house has but how many acres of land for rewilding, carbon sequestration, carbon credits and offsets it has.  Millionaire nature conservation is already a big thing and the democratisation of that is one of the biggest sitting ducks in nature conservation that I can see. A lot of the start ups in green finance are to do with carbon rather than biodiversity so to me there appears to be a massive opportunity for any smart people to crack the democratisation of natural capital financing.  

Anyway, it's a growth area and owning natural capital is good anyway as a lifestyle choice and personal empowerment and private ecological husbandry. Add to that the potential of a speculation bomb and sustained gold rush and you cannot go wrong.     

If you want to know more of this sort of stuff than sign up for CarbonCredit.Com newsletter, InkCap Journal covers everything weekly going on in nature conservation including traditional and new stuff, listen to Financing Nature on Spotify (a United Nations podcast), Dieter Helm's podcast and Mongabay Podcast. Read, read, read, read everything constantly but act slowly and carefully .You won't get this stuff from the RSPB newsletter or the nature conservation establishment because it's all a potential threat to their self preservation societies and their charity mogul model.     

 2. GO BIRDING
The defining feature of a post-capitalist world in an ecosocio-capitalist system (sustainable) is a slower, less rampantly consuming growth model with a wider multi-index value system. i.e a broader definition of capital e..g the concept of natural capital. 

Birders have known this for ever anyway. Instead of pursuing the dollar a lot of birders for years have been pursing the rarity or life list tick. This is an 'economy'  in it's own right. A life list is an extremely valuable commodity and each tick is a valuable currency. 

This idea will presumably be cemented further as biological recording and big data systems gain more power. Your birding data is valuable and at the moment most of us are slaves, building big data systems for free. Having a stake in the game, owning your own land/reserve and using these free to use platforms to monitor your own natural capital is a way of getting your investment back. Presumably in the future in order to mobilise a global reserve big enough to accurately monitor all the world's birds on a daily basis there will need to be incentives to using these platforms and maybe as eco-social credit systems are introduced, universal income will be linked to big data system use. This is a fascinating topic, as it appears birders will evolve from a pioneer/ odd ball community to a valued mainstream global citizen science community central to global ecosystem management.  

So wait for the wave, keep birding, keep building your big data system profile and combine that with your own stake in the game and happy days. 


3. BUILD RESILIENCE
I've got to go so will do this one quickly. The transitioning of our global financial system to a green one will be a total cluster fuck. There will be so many disastrous strategies and stupid ideas (although low-carbon birding has already set the floor in birding). So we are already getting used to this- sudden price rises, inflation, more taxes, lockdowns, insane rules to follow, spiritual leaders telling you slaughter yourself and your personal stake  etc etc. 

Basically during chaos it is critical to have a base camp that is stable and self sufficient. Like the whole of life you want to be in a position to tell anyone or anything to go fuck itself if it's asking you do something against your values and that's what resilience is.

So growing your own food, producing your own energy and having the capability to go off grid and be self sufficient means that no matter what happens out in the fucking mental world it doesn't really matter. If you need to go to ground and disappear and come up when the coast is clear then great.  No money- no problem. No food at the supermarkets- no worries. AI gate has refused you entry - no stress. Everyone is infected with  a real killer virus - time to make an omelet. Pronoun meltdown - top up the feeders. 

If your dependant on the system, which is becoming increasingly chaotic and psychotic as the old world dies and a new world evolves then you could get dragged into all kinds of knee jerk reactions and scams and shams (like the whole covid circus and there is plenty more of that shit coming). 

So build a self sufficient bunker and use that as HQ to coordinate missions from. 

Ok part 3- coming soon- building a network/affinity group and defence. 


Sunday, 25 December 2022

Surviving the ecological emergency. part 1

I've got flu or covid at the moment with a temperature of over 100 F. Laying around in pain seems to send all kind of thoughts swimming to the surface so I thought I'd try and catch some of those and have a rant to take my mind off the discomfort- and share some of that discomfort :-) 

The ecological and climate emergency is becoming a defining narrative of our times and like all narratives will represent some underlying scientific facts and possible futures but more so will provide the driving force for new power struggles, transfers of wealth and the potential for power grabs, new opportunities, new markets, new oppression, new freedoms and new social groups and social structures. Like a journalist said recently about COP27- nobody there cares much about climate change but they all care a lot about making money out of it.  The actual unfolding of the ecological and climate breakdown may pose difficult challenges to e.g.the sustainability of agricultural systems, human societies in most vulnerable areas like flood plains and low lying areas and the sustainability of planetary life support systems but  those threats will pale into insignificance compared to the damage that can be caused by bodged politics and the politicisation and financing of science by nefarious/ exploitative/profiteering interests. 

Fundamentally I don't believe that the ecological and climate emergency can be 'solved' (that seems pretty obvious from the political and ideological division in society over the issues and the endless opportunities in the crisis to capitalise and scavenge from it). There are simply too many people on the way with predicted population growth and more significantly more and more people are expecting higher standards of living putting more demands on natural systems and there are constantly new people and groups rising and seeking power and wealth while whole continents and developing societies demand material and political equity and the pressure on nature that brings. Some of those rising will seek power in the green transition which could be a good thing or an absolutely awful thing (depressed standards of living, higher taxes, crippling price rises, lifestyle lockdowns and our green spaces covered in sterile biofuels, windfarms and solar farms is a green hell which we already seem to be sleep walking into). It's very likely attempts to solve the climate and ecological emergency will generate unimaginable hells in standard play seen in history where hijacking of science or ideology is used to drive oppression and seize power. 

 Fundamentally systems change when they start to eat themselves when they overshoot or overrun, 'divine intervention' comes as tipping points are passed and things start to collapse. That collapse is accelerated partly by 'solutions' to it (scavengers disguised as saviours).  It is from that collapse that the new system emerges. Political systems tend to be cyclical, the end of the cycle being represented by crisis and the seeds for both positive growth and also the next crisis (its redundancy) will be embedded in the new system. It's a simple life-death cycle.  A new system is in no way some kind of ethical ideal but it must be where positive forces out weigh negative ones so is overall positive but in no way perfect. It's simply a better algorithm/system for the new environment which has evolved as a result of societal evolution.  We seem to be moving from a fundamental capitalist cycle to a more eco-socio-capitalist cycle and appear to be in  the crisis stage now.  In that crisis its more the conflict, the resulting power shuffle and the victims and the survivors of that crisis that give rise to the next cycle. It's chaos that leads to change, necessity and despair being the engines of reinvention and not primarily carefully written policy, white papers, grey papers, think tanks, activists, politicians or engineers (most of which is replication, spam and scams, particularly at late stage when most output in the system is junk/noise) . Indeed all of those things if they can provide solutions will be pushed forward in the chaos but chaos is the primary driving force that applies immense natural selection pressures on the drivers of change that emerge from the background 'noise' under the right conditions.

So basically in a crisis/ chaos the threats to individuals is coming from all directions- which is what chaos is. There are threats coming to individuals from all characters in the narrative- from the actual effects of natural breakdown caused by the so called villains in the story e.g. oil companies and fossil fuel hedge fund managers but equally from the supposed heroes in the 'story', the green transition players with green washing, green financial scams, inefficient nature conservation organisations, overpaid NGO CEOs, extremists but more than anything the overpowering stench of bullshit which can be crippling to individuals. As the narrative becomes a global narrative every power house is scrambling around to re-write themselves as the hero in their version of the story from the Global Financial Institutions at COP27, the World Economic Forum Billionaires, Political 'World Leaders' or Extinction Rebellion activists while re-writing each other as the villains. Individuals can easily get caught up in this 'war' whether its becoming a devotee to one of the warring factions or getting stuck on the M25 while some Guardian reading activist glues themselves to Junction 11, getting caught in a global green financial scam , being subjected to green tax rises and price rises and re-conditioning to accept lower standards of living and losing freedom through the power of big data systems and AI and eco-social credit systems.  

So how can an individual not only survive but thrive through the ecological and climate emergency or more so survive the political impacts of the competing narratives of the ecological and climate emergency. Most importantly in the actual cluster fuck of all this how can an individual not only look after themselves and their network but also look after nature- which is likely to be the biggest victim in any global scale botched and bodged political circus of endless human dominance hierarchies and individuals all competing with each other to capitalise on the ecological and climate crisis.

I can't be bothered to write anymore now, I've bored myself too much so I'll do that in part 2 maybe sometime if I can be bothered. 

Happy Xmas! 

Wednesday, 7 December 2022

Azores Ebird Personal Records Update


Getting through the winter work list. Spent the last week digitising my records/notebooks from the Azores since my first visit there in 2001. Turns out my Azores Life List is 253 (although that includes Cat E, Mandarin and Rose-ringed Parakeet but also lumps American Herring Gull and Green-winged Teal). Apparently I'm second in the Azores Ebird listing ranking, with Ruben (top local birder) at No 1. I don't stand much of a chance staying at No 2 as a visitor to the islands but it's been a lot of fun inadvertently listing while exploring.

Here's some of the photos I've uploaded HERE. Azores Ebird HERE.

 It's been a great trip down memory lane from my first visit in 2001 and then the gull exploration trips in the early 2000s (found Short-billed Gull, a first for the WP and lots of other wintering vagrants including 20+ American Herring Gulls, Forster's Tern, Bonaparte's Gulls etc. Write ups HERE and HERE) and then to the ground breaking Corvo 2005 exploration trip (Write ups HERE and HERE; found White-eyed Vireo, a first for the WP and loads more) and then the Pelagic exploration trips from 2007 (Write up HERE). Alongside that the Corvo Autumn birding was growing year on year (Corvo Blog HERE and Reports HERE) and then in more recent years we have been establishing the Natural History Trip and helping to grow the Birding and Wildlife Community (Website HERE). 

An amazing journey and certainly looking forward to the future especially next year with the next exploration trips that will be focusing on the moths and butterflies and trying to find some mega lep migrants.  

It's amazing to think of how much birding and birding technology has changed through the duration of this project and frightening/exciting to think of where it will go over the next 20 years. Presumably the trends will continue upwards towards growing citizen scientists around big data systems (Ebird, I-Naturalist etc) and AI (Merlin, ObsIdentify etc)  with local perspectives (Local Ebird, Local Reports and papers) and development of more sustainable ecotoursim (and less mass tourism etc) and local sustainable system development with closer integration of citizen science and sustainable computer governing systems/social credit/natural capital/carbon credit systems as Capitalist tipping points (climate and ecological collapse) are passed.  


Thursday, 24 November 2022

The message from the crack

I keep a healthy distance from Beddington Farmlands (also known as the crack as its where all London's sewage and waste ends up so is literally the arsehole of London) nowadays but keep what I've learnt from there very close to heart. Here's the latest from My London HERE where the situation is predictably lining up for further deterioration and exploitation. 

Here's a log of the biggest waste of time in my life HERE (but the most important lesson learnt so also the most valuable use of my time) which ended up me getting kicked out the bird group and every local committee despite the fact that I had devoted most of my life at that time to make this community project a success. 

The lesson is clear and a gentle warning to everyone else. Democracy is a farce and society does not 'work'. Private ownership and dominance hierarchies is where primary power lies and anyone who tells you otherwise is trying to limit your power. There is secondary power in democratic fantasies and many high level democracy priests do very well out of disempowering others for payouts from primary power (people like George Monbiot and other prominent 'hard leftists' who get paid well for preaching this bollocks and people working for NGOs funded by Polluters and Ecocidal organisations and do things like name Common Cranes Viridor HERE.) The more people that primary power (via their priests) can convince to sit out of the game, rent and watch others play the more dominance and power they can acquire. From what i can see on environmental social media, a lot of content is propaganda to convince people to do the right thing by owning nothing, not competing  and serving the 'greater good', a familiar 'religious' oppressive strategy that nowadays has replaced Jesus with e.g. Carbon. 

 In theory democracy should work as it's rational- everyone working together should yield greater results (the greater good) but that theory does not take into account human psychology which is a biological algorithm that is wired individualistically, hierarchical and generally short term. Even when this is understood and one individual carries most of the burden of pulling everything together and taking all the risk (like I did) it still doesn't work. The Sutton Biodiversity Officer, Dave Warburton still kicked me off the Science Committee (for things I said about the power hierarchy in a private conversation)  even though there was no risk to himself but rather aimed to win favour in the dominance hierarchy and the same for Marcus Kohler, the site ecologist who campaigned hard to discredit me behind the scenes- again to win favour in the exploitative hierarchy. Even though they could have just permitted my presence they felt they could move up the ladder and score points with superiors by removing me from the equation as I was overall challenging the value extraction agenda but was also suggesting an alternative where value creation was created by the community and NGOs at little cost (maybe a little extra) to the corporation. It was basically in my mind a flawless plan as everyone was a winner and kept their own individual value systems. It was just pulling it together that I was trying to do. However that requires shared inspired belief which is less powerful than fear based belief- which is why the world, in areas, gravitates to inequality, exploitation and decline .

Even Derek Coleman the London Wildlife Trust rep, voted me off the CSG as he didn't want to compromise his position and recently all members of the bird group kept me out of the group following a reshuffle. In short, I as the most prominent and devoted and dedicated Champion of the reserve was outed by the community I was serving and instead they all sided with the Dominance hierarchy- Henry Kravis and his cousin billionaire, KKR, Viridor and Valencia. In this case that dominance hierarchy was an exploitative one to nature as the hierarchy was a fundamental Capitalist ideology.  I do think that all the people who kicked me out will eventually become victim to them too- who needs a council biodiversity officer where government continues to shrink and be starved of resources, who needs a site ecologist when regulation  is being thrown on the bon fire, who needs a conservation NGO when nature conservation is moving into the private sector, who needs a bird group in an area there are no birds left. There will be a justice there as they all rejected a solution so it will be fair result.  

So for me this is the biggest and most important lesson from all this. Landless socio-environmentalists  operating within a democratic system have a weak value system which is easily compromised and very quickly betray each other when faced with low odds . They are very noisy (basically screaming to death and in despair) and tend to dominate social media platforms and attract attention from other people who are also 'screaming to death' so they appear to be 'dominant' and attract large followings but in reality this is just hoards of lemmings following each other off the cliff.  They are basically attempting to impose their values on people higher up the hierarchy, a hierarchy that is also the hand that feeds. They are fighting up hill and attacking an extremely well defended fort which also throws them their survival rations. It's a hopeless strategy. Not only is it a hopeless strategy but it is annoying for primary power (its just unwanted noise that makes no difference to anything) and primary power is now instead of creating the farce of democracy are happy to sacrifice that and get people to accept authoritarianism by seeking to hack vulnerable humans by using big data systems and social media  HERE. Campaigners/activists/socio-environmentalists are increasingly being used to strengthen primary power e.g. Just Stop Oil blocking the M25 etc create a growing hatred for environmentalism. The more extreme and radical that social media drives people to behave in the name of people and planet- the more power to the Fundamental Capitalists and the more they can parade openly as the Authoritarians they are.  

So what is the answer? Well the answer is copying everything above that Fundamental Capitalists do because it's the only thing that works- hacking people, driving inequality, flying the flag of democracy over authoritarian systems, creating fantasies, creating mass delusions but instead of doing it just for money, doing it to create natural and social capital too. Ethically speaking what is wrong with manipulating people into being healthier and happier, what is wrong with inequality when it is responsibility weighted, what is wrong with a fantasy which makes people cope, what is wrong with a delusion that simplifies the world into that something they can be understood. There is a formula to Power and it's the same formula whether it is put to good or not so good outcomes. 

Beddington Farmlands is a largely a lost cause- it's something that will be used for a bit of green wash for an organisation where nature conservation is not part of it's value system (apart from providing a bit of turd polish). Beddington Farmlands is a monument and testament to why democracy/ stakeholder groups do not work , members in these community groups are usually weak and are seeking safety in numbers but when the key stakeholder is predatory that safety is delusional. Private ownership rules the world and whoever wants to make a difference in this world should primarily seek private ownership and land and manage it according to their values and indeed even bring other stakeholders on board at that stage. The world in part (mostly maybe) will often gravitate towards exploitation and decline (especially ecological) and the largest structures on the planet will often generate that. Unfortunately a lot of human life is wasted and used to empower the few but to some kind of degree people choose that so what's wrong with that? I don't know why its just like that- maybe most people are naive and that has enabled societal evolution?.  

There are two main types of potential winners in this game from what I can see - those billionaires and one percenters who own those oppressive structures and create personal paradises from the wider destruction and cost to human wellbeing and the environment and then the other type of winner is those who do the same thing but create personal paradises from their gardens, small farms, small businesses and small passionate endeavours. For the majority of people the best odds are to become winners by being private owners and being the change they want to see and if enough people do that it can make a difference at scale. With enough bullshit (over simplified narratives and noble lies and imagined power hierarchies) too some of those small enterprises can grow into large organisations. People want to feel important because they are not- and key to making a success of anything is understanding that. That can be done in a way that helps people or hurts them. Even though its a long hard road (and lacks the delusional seduction that change can be achieved top down simply) more people need to take power, own land , create jobs,  own environmental businesses and project their values on the world through things they control individually and that.................... is the message from the crack. 

Sunday, 3 July 2022

Festival month begins

A busy July lays ahead and started yesterday with Holly having a stall at the Far Out Festival in Ickford. Tomorrow I'm off to Bulgaria for a week and then it's Bird Fair, then Steve's Wedding, then a family birthday party plus a load of kids birthday parties for Jacob's friends. Thank goodness I'm getting to Bulgaria tomorrow as the thought of spending that much time in society exhausts me before the ordeal has even begun. The social things I enjoy most are demonstrations, secretive society meetings, plotting and blockades against society :-)

Not much to report from the Old Vic since I got back from London. The weather has been cool and wet. There's been a few new for year moths but no news for garden. Generally everything ticking over nicely. Garden Moth year list now 282. Pretty quiet on the bird front. Haven't heard the Spotted Flycatcher in last few days. 

Broad-bordered Yellow Underwing- a nice fresh specimen 
Small Clouded Brindle- if I've identified this correctly this will be a lifer
Yellow tail have started putting in an appearance now 
Not sure if this is a Little Emerald or a Common Emerald with it's darker ground colour and edging worn away? 
I'm presuming this is a Mottled Rustic rather than a heavily marked Uncertain job
Common Rustic agg also now appearing 
Triangle-marked Roller- one of the more regular micros here 
The butterfly border coming along- the Common Loosestrife is now flowering but not many insects about in the day in the rather autumnal conditions 
The cottage garden with plenty flowering now and providing lots of feeding opportunities for insects  
Bryan's coach house border is looking okay- another new area of planting in the garden 
All good at the mini-farm. Bryan's been sorting out the garlic this week (below) 

Holly's stall (above) at the Far Out Festival (below). What with all the food growing and flowers too this weekend, it's all gone a bit full on hippy. Be interesting to get to Bird Fair this month, by the sounds of it, since the re-launch and re-branding to Global Bird Fair, many eco-socialists/carbon commies are keeping away and its just the birding and green Capitalists and their grey army customers. Will see, this could be where birding/ popular natural history forks further into Right (Global, market, high income and technology driven) and Left wing (Local, Low carbon, low income, charity/volunteer, plant and bike based etc)  and if it does there could be an opportunity here for someone to set up a 'Birding Festival'. The old Bird Fair used to represent the whole of the popular natural history community spectrum so in a way if Global Bird Fair has lost some of those 'hippy flavours' it will be a bit sad. Will see. I liked the fact that the old Bird Fair was a place where everyone could come together in one place. Bird Fair was indeed leaning towards the trade fair/capitalist/celebrity camp (the right if you like) a bit too much but things just needed a bit of tweaking/reforming into sustainable/responsible eco-tourism and not a divorce IMHO.